A Citizen Is Dead. The State Is Demanding Your Silence.
A death in a neighborhood, and a national message meant to make it feel normal.
Renee Nicole Macklin Good is dead.
Thirty-seven. A U.S. citizen. A mother of three. A poet. A writer. A human being with a life that didn’t belong to the government, right up until the moment the government decided it did.
An ICE officer fired into her vehicle and she died.
Before the podiums. Before the spin. Watch what actually happened.
I’m not going to sand that down into “a fatal incident.” That phrase is how people in suits hide what happened behind soft, manageable edges. A federal agent fired. A woman died. That is state violence, up close, in a neighborhood, in the kind of place where people take kids to school and bring groceries home and expect the rule of law to mean something other than “trust us.”
And then it happened again, just with different weapons.
The second violence was the speed. How fast they tried to tell you what you saw. How fast they tried to name the dead. How fast they tried to make the story feel finished.
Not after evidence. Not after transparency. First.
So, here’s what seems true because it’s been widely reported and seen on video:
Renee Good was shot and killed by an ICE officer during a federal operation in Minneapolis.
Video exists and spread immediately.
Here’s what is being claimed, loudly, by people with a political interest in closing the case in public:
That this was clean “self-defense.”
That she “weaponized” her vehicle.
That this is “domestic terrorism,” coordinated, part of a “network.”
And here’s what we do not know yet, no matter how confident anyone sounds on TV:
We do not know what was in Renee’s head in that split second. Panic and intent are not the same thing.
We do not have a full public timeline of commands, positions, warnings, and escalation.
We do not have all evidence publicly released, and we do not have the kind of independent access that earns trust.
That’s what seriousness looks like when the people with the guns also control the story.

He posted that into the world while the evidence was still contested and local officials were saying the official story didn’t match what the video showed.
MINNEAPOLIS IS TALKING ABOUT ACCOUNTABILITY.
WASHINGTON IS TALKING ABOUT DOMINANCE.
Mayor Jacob Frey looked at the federal story and refused to play along. Not “we’re monitoring the situation.” Not “we’re waiting for more information.” He watched the video and said the self-defense framing didn’t match what he saw.
“Having seen the video myself, I want to tell everybody directly — that is bullshit.” — Mayor Jacob Frey
Governor Tim Walz didn’t just dispute the narrative either. He warned people about the strategy. Don’t take the bait. Don’t give them the clip they want. Don’t let a tragedy get turned into a pretext.
That’s what it sounds like when local leaders believe federal power is moving through their city like it’s untouchable, and then asking the public to clap for it.
Now look at Washington.
DHS Secretary Kristi Noem didn’t talk like someone waiting on facts. She talked like someone trying to lock a verdict in place before the evidence can.
Weaponized vehicle. Domestic terrorism.
Coordinated. Organized. Attack.
Those aren’t just words. They’re tools. They are meant to do one thing: make the public stop asking questions and start accepting escalation as “order.”
“Domestic terrorism” is their permission slip.
“She… weaponized her vehicle… and she attempted to run a law enforcement officer over.” — Kristi Noem
And here’s the part that should scare each and every one of us, even if you hate both parties, even if you’ve been checked out for years, even if you’re exhausted from all of it.
They’re asking the public to accept a verdict written by the same machine that did the killing.
Before the evidence is fully public, before a timeline is on the record, before anyone outside that system has real access, the White House and DHS are speaking with absolute certainty. Like the facts belong to them. Like your job is to nod along.
If your first instinct after killing a citizen is to control the evidence chain and flood the zone with certainty, you’re not trying to find the truth. You’re trying to own it.
This is where JD Vance matters. Because the briefing he gave today was their blueprint.
If you watched it, you watched the state try to end the argument by force of narrative. Not by releasing evidence. Not by putting the timeline on the record. By telling you what you’re allowed to believe.
They framed it as a “sinister left-wing movement.” They threw wild percentage claims around like smoke grenades. They talked about “networks” and “funding.” They treated outrage as the danger and accountability as illegitimate. They floated immunity language like it was a spell meant to shut local leaders up and shut the public out.
And then they did the oldest move in state violence…
They tried to put the dead on trial at the podium.
Not just “she did X.” Not just “she endangered an officer.”
A whole character sketch meant to make her death feel deserved, and your anger feel shameful.
“This was an attack on the American people.” — JD Vance
No defense was offered. Instead, the White House issued the warning that your grief is suspicious, your questions are dangerous.
WHO RENEE WAS, AND WHY THE RUMOR FLOOD IS PART OF THE MACHINE
I’m seeing what you’re seeing. The internet went to work immediately.
Not on the facts. On her.
Lesbian. Activist. Not activist. Three kids. Two kids. Husband dead. Husband a veteran. Wife. Partner. Network. Paid agitator.
It looks like chaos. It isn’t. It’s the system.
If they can’t prove she was a threat, they’ll turn her into a question mark. If they can’t make you hate her, they’ll make you unsure enough to stop caring. Keep you arguing about labels while the evidence stays out of reach.
I’m not doing that.
I’m not repeating rumors because they make a paragraph punch harder. I’m not trading a dead woman’s name for a cleaner argument. If we’re going to talk about accountability, we’re going to do it clean.
Here’s what I’m willing to say without turning her into a character in anybody’s script:
Renee Good was a U.S. citizen. She was a mother. People who knew her describe compassion and love, a life built around taking care of other people. Now her children have to grow up with the kind of absence that doesn’t “heal” on a timeline. The government killed their mom. Then powerful people went looking for a story that would make that feel normal.
That’s why the rumor pile grows so fast. Confusion buys time. Confusion drains empathy. Confusion turns a killing into an argument about vibes.
Don’t fall for it.
Say her name without turning her into a character in somebody else’s script.
The killing is the headline. The cover story is the governance.
A mother drops her kid off at school and ends up dead in her car. Then the most powerful people in the country show up on camera and try to make the death feel tidy. Necessary. Inevitable. The kind of thing you’re supposed to accept as the price of order.
The part they never say out loud is that your job is to get used to it.
Used to armed federal agents moving through neighborhoods. Used to a body becoming a political prop. Used to the word “terrorism” being slapped on grief so the public will shut up. Used to “self-defense” being declared before the evidence is public.
They want you numb. They want you tired. They want you arguing about rumors while they keep the facts behind a locked door.
And they want you to feel guilty for being angry.
I’m not going to do that. I’m not going to tell you to lower your voice while the state keeps raising the stakes. If a government can kill a citizen and then stand at a podium and scold the country for reacting like human beings, that’s not law and order.
That’s those in power training you.
Training you to look away.
Training you to accept the badge as a blank check.
Training you to swallow the cover story faster than you swallow the truth.
So no, I don’t want “trust us.” I don’t want “internal review.” I don’t want the same machine that fired the shots grading its own violence and calling it justice.
I want the record. All of it.
Every angle. Every report. Every command. A real timeline. Real oversight with real access. Because if the state wants to be believed, it can start by acting like it understands what it took.
Amd if they want to talk about “turning down the temperature,” here’s the only honest way to do it…
Stop treating our communities like a battlefield.
Stop treating accountability like an attack.
Stop killing people and then asking us to clap.
Renee Good is dead. The state killed her.
Now they’re trying to decide what her death is allowed to mean.
Don’t let them.



Right on Chase! Heather Cox Richardson is calling this kind of thing racism verging on totalitarianism -- where the state wants to control what you think. Today a twit in Chuck Fleichmann's office engaged in the same crap in a rude and disrespectful way when I called his Washington office -- great constituent services there!